had occasionally indulged in allusions which he did not care to have laid to his door; and sometimes, too, Steele, who was always in a hurry, forgot to distinguish his own papers from those of his friend. Thus, No. 18, which he ascribes to Addison in his preface, was omitted in the list which he gave to Tickell. Hurd, indeed, pretends that there was an immeasurable distance between the two writers, and in the papers which they wrote together, points you out with a confidence not unworthy of Warburton himself, the very spot in which one stopped and the other began. Nichols, however, with better judgment, sought for more positive testimony, and has succeeded, by means of tradition, contemporary records and internal evidence, in detecting the hand of Addison in several pieces which had always been attributed to Steele. A full account of the method which he followed in this process of restoration will be found in his edition of the Tatler. Subsequent editors have followed his example, and in most of the reprints of that work since the appearance of his edition several papers are assigned to Addison which are not admitted either by Tickell or Hurd. Thus the second part of No. 18 is omitted by Tickell, though Steele in the preface to vol. iv. of the Tatler, clearly points to Addison as its author. In No. 24 the case is not so clear. Nichols refers to Tickell-but why was it omitted in Tickell's edition? or where else does he mention it? The internal evidence is not decisive, the manner having full as much of Steele as of Addison-even supposing that it were always possible to distinguish them. It should be observed, however, that Nichols generally cites the Baskerville edition as Tickell's-though it is, I believe, merely a reprint of the original edition of 1721. For a fuller account of this subject I would refer to the Introduction to the American reprint of Nichols's edition of the Tatler, Guardian, and Spectator, which will be given as the complement of the present edition of Addison. The notes marked N. are by Nichols-those with a star from the edition of the British Essayists, London, 1825, 3 vols. 8vo. Hurd's and those of the present editor are distinguished in the same way as in the other volumes of this edition. Hurd says: "We now enter on those parts of Mr. Addison's proseworks, which have done him the greatest honour, and have placed him at the head of those, whom we call our polite writers. I know that many readers prefer Dr. Swift's prose to his :--but whatever other merit the Dean's writings may have (and they have, certainly, a great deal), I affirm it with confidence (because I have examined them both with care) that they are not comparable to Mr. Addison's, in the correctness, propriety, and elegance of expression. "Mr. Addison possessed two talents, both of them very uncommon, which singularly qualified him to excel in the following essays: I mean an exquisite knowledge of the English tongue, in all its purity and delicacy and a vein of humour, which flowed naturally and abundantly from him on every subject; and which experience hath shown to be inimitable. But it is in the former respect only, that I shall criticise these papers; and I shall do it with severity, lest time, and the authority of his name (which, of course, must become sacred), should give a sanction even to his defects. If any man of genius should be so happy, as to equal all the excellencies of his prose, and to avoid the few blemishes, which may, haply, be found in it, he would be a perfect model of style, in this way of writing: but of such an one, it is enough to say at present (and I shall, surely, offend no good writer in saying it), THE TATLER. No. 18. SATURDAY, MAY 21, 1709. [The first part of this paper was written by Steele. Addison begins with the distress of news-writers if the negotiations for peace should prove successful.-G.] THERE is another sort of gentlemen whom I am much more concerned for, and that is the ingenious fraternity of which I have the honour to be an unworthy member; I mean the newswriters of Great Britain, whether post-men or post-boys," or by what other name or title soever dignified or distinguished. The case of these gentlemen is, I think, more hard than that of the soldiers, considering that they have taken more towns, and fought more battles. They have been upon parties and skirmishes, when our armies have lain still; and given the general assault to many a place, when the besiegers were quiet in their trenches. They have made us masters of several strong towns many weeks before our generals could do it; and completed victories, when our greatest captains have been glad to come off with a drawn battle. Where prince Eugene has slain his thousands, Boyer has slair his ten thousands. This gentleman can indeed be never enough commended for his courage and intrepidity during this a The Post-boy' was a scandalous weekly paper, by Abel Roper; ard The Flying-Post,' by George Ridpath, was just such another.-N. Abel Boyer, author of 'The Political Staze.'-N. There whole war he has laid about him with an inexpressible fury; and, like the offended Marius of ancient Rome, has made such havoc among his countrymen, as must be the work of two or three ages to repair. It must be confessed, the redoubted Mr. Buckley has shed as much blood as the former; but I cannot forbear saying (and I hope it will not look like envy) that we regard our brother Buckley as a kind of Drawcansir, who spares neither friend nor foe; but generally kills as many of his own side as the enemy's. It is impossible for this ingenious sort of men to subsist after a peace: every one remembers the shifts they were driven to in the reign of king Charles the Second, when they could not furnish out a single paper of news, without lighting up a comet in Germany, or a fire in Moscow. scarce appeared a letter without a paragraph on an earthquake Prodigies were grown so familiar, that they had lost their name, as a great poet of that age has it. I remember Mr. Dyer," who is justly looked upon by all the fox-hunters in the nation as the greatest statesman our country has produced, was particularly famous for dealing in whales; insomuch, that in five months time (for I had the curiosity to examine his letters on that occasion) he brought three into the mouth of the river Thames, besides two porpoises and a sturgeon. The judicious and wary Mr. Ichabod Dawks hath all along been the rival of this great writer, and got himself a reputation from plagues and famines; by which, in those days, he destroyed as great multitudes as he has lately done by the sword. In every dearth of news, Grand Cairo was sure to be unpeopled. It being therefore visible, that our society will be greater a Samuel Buckley, printer of 'The Gazette,' and also of 'The Daily Courant.'-N. b 'Dyer's Letter;' a news-paper of that time, which, according to Mr Addison, was entitled to little credit.-N. • Ichabod Dawks, another poor epistolary historian.-N. sufferers by the peace than the soldiery itself, insomuch that the Daily Courant is in danger of being broken, my friend Dyer of being reformed, and the very best of the whole band of being reduced to half-pay; might I presume, to offer any thing in the behalf of my distressed brethren, I would humbly move, that an appendix of proper apartments furnished with pen, ink, and paper, and other necessaries of life, should be added to the hospital of Chelsea, for the relief of such decayed news-writers as have served their country in the wars; and that, for their exercise, they should compile the annals of their brother veterans, who have been engaged in the same service, and are still obliged to do duty after the same manner. I cannot be thought to speak this out of an eye to any private interest; for, as my chief scenes of action are coffee-houses, play-houses, and my own apartment, I am in no need of camps, fortifications, and fields of battle, to support me; I do not call for heroes and generals to my assistance. Though the officers are broken, and the armies disbanded, I shall still be safe, as long as there are men, or women, or politicians, or lovers, or poets, or nymphs, or swains, or cits, or courtiers, in being. No. 20. THURSDAY, MAY 26, 1709. [First part by Steele.-G.] --THOUGH the theatre is now breaking, it is allowed still to sell animals there; therefore, if any lady or gentleman have occasion for a tame elephant, let them inquire of Mr. Pinkethman,' who has one to dispose of at a reasonable rate. The downfal of May 1 Chief of a company of strolling players-mentioned in Tat.er. No 4.-G. |