fust retournable, qar a cel jour deit le jugement A.D. 1340. referrer.-Et non potuit habere.— Quare.1 Et nota, Priour dun soit em ceo nest (14.) § Un bref daille fut porte vers le mestre del Aiel. Hospital de Seynt Mark juste Bristuit.-Et conta si un de la seisine son aiel en temps le Roi E. aiel 5 le Roi Abbe ou qore est, et fist la descente a soun pere et de soun Hospy talle pere a luy, &c.--Derw. Vous avez icy le Mestre qe plede par vous dit qe ceo qe est en demande il le tient com un estparcel et dreit del Hospital, quel Hospital il tient al range, terme de sa vie de la collacion un J. de E., et prioms pas plee eide de luy et del Ordiner.-Pole. Vous moustrez pur eux a dire qils mesmes qe vous naverez mye leyde, qar vous ditez qe sount tenez la terre com de dreit de vostre Hospital et ne donez a nully la reversion. Ovesqe ceo, nous vous vie, la redioms qe vostre Hospital est une Eglise college, ou &c., et vous serrez eslieu, par vos confreres et avez comune priount seal com un Abbe ou un Priour; par quei vous ne ils ount devez eide aver.-Stouff. Eleccion ne put estre en- altre estat tendu de ley mes la ou il y ad Covent, et vous dioms a terme de qe par nostre awowe nous serroms presente al Ordiner, vie, qar et il nous rescey vra a son presentement; issint la pondront tenoms nous 9 la collacion a 10 nostre avowe; par quei et pledront tenantz a terme de version eide, qar qe tenant en chief 1 There are added in a later hand (apparently of the 16th century) references to similar cases by years and folios, but not by folios of the same (Temple) MS. They may, perhaps, be identified with the following reports in the printed Year Books:-Easter, 6 Ed. III., No. 14, and Hilary, 7 Ed. III., No. 13. 2 From L. and 25184 until otherwise stated, but corrected by the record Placita de Banco, Trinity, 14 Edward III., R°. 94. It there appears that the action was brought of by Alexander son Andrew Luterel against the Master of the House of Saint Mark of Billeswyk their churches, as more pears in this plea; and this is right, and occurs also in other places. We A.D. 1840. SCHARDELOWE. Many an Abbot and many a Prior of a church might be elected and afterwards presented to the patron, and the patron might then present them to the fully ap- Ordinary, and yet they shall never have aid either of the one or of the other.-Blaik. Abbots and Priors shall not have aid because they have a higher estate than a term for life, for they hold in right of their church &c.-SCHARDELOWE. And such an estate have you, for, if your predecessor had aliened without the assent of his fellow brethren, you would have an action to demand the same land by writ of Entry sine assensu Capituli; wherefore &c.-W. Thorpe. In that case we could have the Jurata utrum, just as a parson might have it; wherefore &c.-SCHARDELOWE. You could not, for you have it not at common law, and by this new Statute it is granted to the Wardens of Chapels and Chantries, because they had not any other recovery, but The tenant you have another remedy (as above).-Stouford. pleaded in tell you that, in the time of King Henry, the greatcovery had grandfather of the present King, one Gilbert, our preagainst the decessor, brought an assise of Novel Disseisin against ant's anthis same person your grandfather, then tenant, and cestor, whereupon against others, and recovered; judgment whether, upon the de- his death, you can maintain this action annulled in law by this record.-Blaik. We have counted of his seisin since that recovery; wherefore it seems that you do and made not answer to us at all.-W. Thorpe. If your father title; and had brought a Mort d'Ancestor, such a plea as we plead would have been a good plea to deprive him of the would assise; so also in this case.-Blaik. In a Mort d'Ancespelled him tor there is no certain time limited at which the ancestor died seised, but in this action we have shown a certain as to how time by our count. However, to avoid delay, we tell you that, since the time of King Henry, our grandfather died seised; ready &c.-SCHARDELOWE. You ought to bar a re demand mandant was com pelled to show title, then the tenant have com to have answered the recovery was defeated, 1 14 Edward III., Stat. 1, c. 17. droit de come pluis en cest hoc bene, et auxi en lieuz, &c. nous prioms leide.-SCHARD. Maynte Abbe et maynt A.D. 1340. Priour en Eglise serroit eslieuz et pus presente al com de patron, et il donqes les presentera al Ordiner, et si lour eglinaverount ils jammes eyde ne de lun ne de lautre.-- sez et siBlaik. Abbez et Priourz naverount mye eide pur ceo pleyneqils unt plus haut estat qa terme de vie, qar ils tenent ment piert en le dreit de lour Eglise, &c.-SCHAR.1 Autiel estat plee; et avez vous, qar, si vostre predecessour ust aliene sanz assent de ses 2 confreres, vous averez accion a de- altres, mander mesme la terre par bref dentre sine assensu capituli; par quei, &c.-W. Thorpe. En ceo cas nous pooms aver le jure de utrum, auxi com persone navera; par quei, &c.-SCHAR. Noun poiez, qar a la comune ley vous nel avez mye, et par cest noveile estatut il est grante as gardeyns dez chapelles et des chaunteries, pur ceo qe eux navoient mye autre recoverir, mes vous. avez altre remedy, ut supra.--Stouf. Nous vous dioms qen temps le Roi H. besails le Roi quore est un Le tenant pleda en Gilbert, nostre predecessour, porta une assise de novele barre par disseisine devers mesme celui vostre aiel, adonqes un retenant, et devers altres, et recoveri; jugement si, de il recoveri la morte celuy, par cel record aneynti en ley poiez vers soun cest accion mayntener.-Blaik. Nous avoms counte ou le dede sa seisine pus cel recoverir; par quei il semble qe fut chace vous ne responez rienz a nous.-W. Thorpe. Si vostre de moustrer title, pere ust porte un mordancestre, tiel plee com nous pledoms ust este boun plee de luy aver tolle lassise; title; et auxi pardecea.-Blaik. En un mordancestre il ny ad pus le vonul certeyn temps lymite quant il morust seisi, mes chace daen ceo bref nous lavoms moustre par nostre conte. pondu Mes, pur hastiver, nous vous dioms qe, pus le temps coment le le Roi H., nostre aiel morust seisi; prest, &c.-SCHARD. fust defait, Vous devez moustrer coment il aveynt, qar par le et il ne fut 5 coverir qe auncestre, mandant et fist dreit aver ver res recoverir and he was not to do that, for that to show title upon below. A.D. 1340. show how he became seised, for his estate was defeated by the judgment, and in law we hold that to be executed, compelled &c.-Blaik said gratis :-Since the time at which the recovery is alleged, one Geoffrey de Luterel was seised would be in his demesne as of fee and of right, and enfeoffed our grandfather, and so our grandfather was seised, and died title. See seised; ready, &c.-Stouford. Sir, you see clearly that he does not deny the recovery had by our predecessor, which recovery must be understood in law to be executed; wherefore he shall not be admitted to say that Geoffrey was seised since this recovery, without showing how our predecessor became divested of the possession which he had by the recovery.-STONORE. You said before that he should not be admitted without showing how his ancestor became seised, and he has met you as to that; wherefore, do you desire more? as meaning to say, that is sufficient.--Stouford. Sir, we tell you then that our predecessor recovered (as above) and that estate continued until he died; and after his death we entered, and we have continued that estate until the present time, without this that this Geoffrey ever had anything so that he could make a feoffment; ready &c.-STONORE. Now it seems that you have traversed his writ, for you have alleged continuance of estate since that recovery, and he has taken this action upon the seisin of his ancestor who died seised at a later time; wherefore it seems that, in this case, he ought in law to aver his writ. W. Thorpe. In speaking of continuance of estate, we do not put it as the effect of our recovery, for we do not rely upon that, but we traverse the special cause 3 6 a ceo, qar title sur jugement son estat fut defait, et nous le entendoms A.D. 1340. de ley1 execut, &c.2- Blaik dit de gree qe puis le mye chace temps qil allegga soun recoverir qe un Geffre de ceo serreit Luterel fut seisi en son demene cum de fee et de a mostrer dreit, et enfeffa nostre aiel, issint fut il seisi et morust title. Vide seisi; prest, &c.-Stouff. Sire, vous veiez bien coment inferius. il ne dedit mye le recoverir fait par nostre predecessour, quel recoverir deit estre entendu par ley execut; par quei a dire qe puis cel recoverir Geffre 8 fuit seisi navendra il poynt sanz moustrer coment nostre predecessour fut demys de la possession quel il avoit par le recoverir. STON. Altrefoitz vous deistez qil navendra mye sanz moustrer coment son auncestre avynt, et a cella vous ad il servy; par quei voletz vous plus? quasi diceret cella suffit.-Stouff. Sire, donqes vous dioms nous qe nostre predecessour recoveri, ut supra, et cel estat continua tanqez il morust, apres qi mort nous entrames, et cel estat avoms continue tanqe en cea, sanz ceo qe celuy Geffre 10 navoit unqes rienz issint qil put feffement faire; prest, &c.-STON. Ore semble il qe vous avetz traverse son bref, qar vous avez moustre continuance pus cel recoverir, et il ad prise cest accion de lasseisine son auncestre qe morust seisi de pusne temps; par quei il semble qil doit de ley, en ceo cas, averer son bref.-W. Thorpe. Ceo qe nous parloms de continuance nest pas leffecte de nostre recoverir, qar nous ne reposoms my la,13 eynz traversoms la cause especial 9 12 |