Those who voted for Hon. T. J. Robertson are: Messrs. Greene, Montgomery, Nash, Owens, Smalls, Swails, Whittemore.-7. Those who voted for Hon. D. H. Chamberlain are: Messrs. Allen, Corbin, Duncan, Leslie, Rose.-5. Those who voted for Hon. F. L. Cardozo are: Messrs. Barber, Cardozo, Dickson, Hayne, Johnston -5. Mr. Maxwell voted for Hon. Reuben Tomlinson. Mr. Wimbush voted for Hon. F. J. Moses, Sr. Mr. McIntyre voted for Hon. J. L. Neagle. Necessary to a choice ..27 ...14 No candidate having received a majority of the whole number of votes given, the Senate proceeded to a THIRD BALLOT. Those who voted for Hon. T. J. Robertson are: Messrs. Duncan, Greene, Maxwell, Montgomery, Nash, Owens, Rose, Smalls, Swails, Whittemore.-10. Those who voted for Mr. M. C. Butler are: Messrs. Arnim, Bieman, Burroughs, Duvall, Foster, Holcombe, Wilson.-7. Those who voted for Hon. F. L. Cardozo are: Messrs. Barber, Cardozo, Dickson, Hayne, Johnston, McIntyre.-6. Those who voted for Hon. D. H. Chamberlain are: No candidate having received a majority of the whole number of votes. given, the Senate proceeded to a FOURTH BALLOT. Those who voted for Hon. T. J. Robertson are: Messrs. Dickson, Duncan, Greene, Montgomery, Nash, Owens, Smalls, Swails and Whittemore.-9. Those who voted for Mr. M. C. Butler are: Messrs. Arnim, Bieman, Burroughs, Duvall, Foster, Holcombe and Wilson.-7. Those who voted for Hon. D. H. Chamberlain are: Messrs. Allen, Corbin, Hayes, Leslie and Maxwell.-5. Those who voted for Hon. F. L. Cardozo are: Messrs. Barber, Cardozo, Hayne and Johnston.-4. Those who voted for Hon. F. J. Moses, Sr., are: Messrs. Rose and Wimbush.-2. Mr. McIntyre voted for Mr. M. R. Delaney. Whole number of votes given...... Necessary to a choice..... ......28 .........15 No candidate having received a majority of the whole number of votes given, the Senate proceeded to a FIFTH BALLOT. Those who voted for Mr. M. C. Butler are: Messrs. Arnim, Bieman, Burroughs, Duvall, Foster, Holcombe and Wilson.-7. Those who voted for Hon.T. J. Robertson are: Messrs. Duncan, Greene, Montgomery, Nash, Owens, Swails and Whittemore -7. Those who voted for Hon. F. L. Cardozo are: Messrs. Barber, Cardozo, Dickson, Hayne, Johnston and Maxwell.-6 Those who voted for Hon. D. H. Chamberlain are: Messrs Allen, Corbin, Hayes and Leslie.-4. Those who voted for Hon. F. J. Moses, Sr., are: Messrs. Rose and Wimbush.-2. Mr. McIntyre voted for Hon. A. J. Ransier. Whole number of votes given........ Necessary to a choice...... .27 .14 No candidate having received a majority of the whole number of votes given, the Senate proceeded to a SIXTH BALLOT. Those who voted for Hon. T. J. Robertson are: Messrs. Duncan, Greene, Maxwell, Nash, Owens, Rose, Swails, Whittemore.-8. Those who voted for Mr. M. C. Butler are: Messrs. Arnim, Bieman, Burroughs, Duvall, Foster, Holcombe, Wilson.-7. Those who voted for Hon. D. H. Chamberlain are: Those who voted for Hon. F. L. Cardozo are: Messrs. Barber, Cardozo, Dickson, Hayne, Johnston.-5. Messrs. McIntyre, Smalls.-2. Whole number of votes given....... Necessary to a choice...... .27 ..14 No candidate having received a majority of the votes given, the Senate proceeded to a SEVENTH BALLOT. Those who voted for Hon. T. J. Robertson are: Messrs. Duncan, Greene, Montgomery, Nash, Owens, Smalls, Swails, Whittemore.-8. Those who voted for Mr. M. C. Butler are: Messrs. Arnim, Bieman, Burroughs, Duvall, Foster, Holcombe, Wilson.-7. Those who voted for Hon. F. L. Cardozo are: Messrs. Barber, Cardozo, Dickson, Hayne, Maxwell.-5. Those who voted for Hon. D. H. Chamberlain are: Messrs. Allen, Corbin, Hayes, Leslie.-4. Those who voted for Hon. F J. Moses, Sr., are: Messrs. Johnston, Rose, Wimbush.-3. Mr. McIntyre voted for Hon. C. W. Montgomery. Whole number of votes given...... 28 ....15 No candidate having received a majority of the whole number of votes given, the Senate proceeded to an EIGHTH BALLOT. Those who voted for Mr. M. C. Butler are: Messrs. Arnim, Bieman, Burroughs, Duncan, Duvall, Foster, Holcombe, Wilson.-8. Those who voted for Hon. T. J. Robertson are: Messrs. Greene, Montgomery, Nash, Swails, Whittemore.-5. Those who voted for Hon D. H. Chamberlain are: Messrs. Allen, Corbin, Leslie, Maxwell.-4. Those who voted for Hon. F. L. Cardozo are: Messrs. Barber, Cardozo, Dickson, Hayne.-4. Those who voted for Hon. C. W. Montgomery are: Mr. Rose voted for Hon. W. B. Nash. Whole number of votes given...... Necessary to a choice....... 27 14 No candidate having received a majority of the whole number of votes given, the Senate proceeded to a NINTH BALLOT. Those who voted for Hon. T. J. Robertson are: Messrs. Duncan, Greene, Montgomery, Nash, Owens, Smalls, Swails and Whittemore.-8. Those who voted for Mr. M. C. Butler are: Messrs. Arnim, Bieman, Burroughs, Duvall, Foster, Holcombe and Wilson.-7. Those who voted for Hon. F. L. Cardozo are: Messrs. Barber, Cardozo, Dickson, Hayne, Johnston and Maxwell.-6. Whole number of votes given....... Necessary to a choice.......... 28 15 No candidate having received a majority of the whole number of votes given, Mr. ROSE moved that the Senate adjourn. On the question of agreeing to the motion of the Senator from York, Mr. SWAILS called for the yeas and nays. The yeas and nays were taken, and resulted as follows: Yeas-Messrs. Arnim, Barber, Bieman, Burroughs, Cardozo, Corbin, Dickson, Duncan, Duvall, Foster, Hayne, Holcombe, Johnston, Rose and Wilson.-15. Nays-Messrs. Greene, Hayes, Leslie, Maxwell, McIntyre, Nash, Owens, Smalls, Swails, Whittemore and Wimbush.-11. The PRESIDENT announced the Senate adjourned at 1:50 P. M. WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 7, 1870. Pursuant to adjournment, the Senate assembled at 12 M., and was called to order by the President, Hon. A. J. RANSIER. The roll was called, and, a quorum answering to their names, the PRESIDENT announced that, in accordance with the requirements of "An Act to regulate the time and manner of holding elections for Senators in Congress," the Senate would proceed to the hall of the House of Representatives, to unite with that body in voting for a person to repre sent the State of South Carolina in the Senate of the United States, for a term of six years, commencing March 4, 1871. The Senate proceeded to the hall of the House of Representatives. JOINT ASSEMBLY. The two Houses having met in Joint Assembly, it was called to order by Hon. A. J. RANSIER, President of the Senate. The President announced that, pursuant to Act of Congress, the two Houses were now in Joint Assembly, for the purpose of hearing read so much of the Journals of both Houses as relates to the votes given in each House for a person to represent the State of South Carolina in the Senate of the United States, for a term of six years, commencing March 4, 1871. The Journals were read. The PRESIDENT announced the following as the result of the votes given in each House: The PRESIDENT announced that no candidate having received a majority, the Joint Assembly would now proceed to vote for a person to represent the State of South Carolina in the Senate of the United States for a term of six years, commencing March 4, 1871. |